You can see everything
- ➢ Home
- ➢ Blog posts
I finally got the chance to see You Can See Everything last week. Definitely lived up to expectations!
The film is meant to be a mind-bender, which will come as no surprise to anyone who’s seen Nathan Fielder’s prior work, notably The Rehearsal. Fielder’s central message is that self-referential art creates non-falsifiability. Once a piece of art reflects on itself, once a subject meets the artist who portrays her, once we see the process from the inside - then it becomes impossible to know whether the art is faithfully portraying reality, or willfully distorting it. He works with the documentary format in order to subvert it. Fielder is to art what Kurt Gödel was to mathematics.
Hence this misleadingly-titled movie, inspired by a text Elizabeth Holmes sent to Fielder early in the filming process. The idea is that she’s trying to be as transparent as possible, to give Fielder full access to her life in order to acquit herself in the court of public opinion. And indeed, maybe Fielder was able to see everything (despite Billy Evans’s sporadic attempts to disrupt or control the process.) But that doesn’t mean that we, the audience, had that same access! Of course we didn’t: no one wants to see a full month of footage, and we rely on some degree of editing to cut away the boring parts and create a compelling movie.
We get plenty of editing in this movie, in fact far too much. The first 15 minutes or so of the movie are extreme close-ups of one face or another, so we can see exactly which bits of stubble Fielder missed in his last shaving attempt. It’s aggressively uncomfortable film editing, so that when we revert to more conventional wide-angle shots of a couple prepping breakfast in the kitchen, we breathe a sigh of relief.
It’s out of the frying pan, into the fire, though: pretty soon the film is edited into a love triangle. In one scene, Fielder screens The Dropout for Holmes, while he, Holmes, and Evans sit together on the couch. The camera swings around to film the three of them. Evans and Holmes are cuddling up, as you’d imagine; the camera angle makes it appear that Fielder is practically touching Holmes as well, though in fact there’s a fair amount of space between them. Fielder and Holmes have many intimate conversations. The picture of Holmes’s face that adorns movie posters is from one such scene, in which she and Fielder are twisted toward each other, rather awkwardly, and in that contortion it appears their faces are nearly touching. Finally there’s an infamous scene, on the day of Holmes’s surrender, which is edited to suggest that the two are about to kiss before she gets in the car. The whole thing is a gimmick, as far as I can tell, meant to sell the film and nothing more. Nothing wrong with that, but it is kind of silly.
Then there are the intentional omissions. Most notably, there is the episode when Fielder, taking a call from Holmes on a prison phone, intentionally cuts the sound. The concern is that if Holmes participates in a call that winds up in a movie, she could be transferred to another prison.
But there are other omissions, some more befuddling. Holmes and Evans go to great lengths to contest a quote in Amy Chozick’s May 2023 New York Times profile, “Liz Holmes Wants You to Forget About Elizabeth.” In the Times, Holmes is quoted as saying “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created.” She claims that what she actually said was, “… a character they created.” Furthermore, she and Evans claim to have extensive recordings of every interview she ever conducted, so that they can easily refute the quote. The next step should be obvious: pull up the recording, play back the tape, and definitively dispute the quote. Pretty simple! But they never do it. And Fielder, who grills his subjects about every little detail - why they smile, which way they whisk their eggs - never presses the point. In one conversation with Holmes he drives home the importance of getting to the truth of the matter, quite intensely - but never follows through. In point of fact, the truth of the matter is actually pretty inconsequential: obviously Holmes’s public persona was partly her creation, partly that of the media, and certainly a distortion of her authentic self. That is true of every public figure. (Chozick, for her part, has since weighed in with her side of the story.)
More consequential is Fielder’s deep dive into Holmes’s statement from a 2014 Fortune interview: “we have a machine that can do any test.” This sort of statement, though not this exact one, is what sent Holmes to prison: misleading investors about the technology her company was designing. Fielder confronts Holmes about the sentence - the machine they had was not, in fact, capable of doing any test. Holmes responds that the machine was built in such a way that it could be capable of doing any test, at some point in the future. It’s essentially a grammatical Rorschach test based on multiple definitions of the word “can”, and in true Fielder fashion the conversation is five times as awkward as it needs to be. The whole thing is downstream of her earlier claim that she had never, in her entire adult life, told a lie. Not even an innocent one!
Throughout the film, Holmes portrays herself as an ingenue, a sweet beachside mom who just wants the truth to get out there and her kids to eat vegetables. She’s devoted to - no, besotted with and deferential to - her partner. There’s no hint of her erstwhile captain-of-industry public image. The closest we get to that is when we see her trying to sell some investors on the next iteration of her diagnostic machine, what she calls “Theranos 2.0.” She seems refreshed and invigorated to be doing something she feels she was born to do. Let’s set aside for a moment the most obvious question: What on earth is she doing inventing a new company just days before she goes to jail!
Fielder is a willing accomplice in crafting that image, and there are plenty of scenes of wholesome family time. His film constructs a villain out of Evans, who comes across as a deceitful, controlling, shady operator. The text of the movie questions Holmes’s sincerity and her accountability for the Theranos fraud; but the subtext very clearly points to Evans as the true evil genius behind the scenes. (Though to be clear, he is quite obviously innocent of any wrongdoing related to her case - the two did not even meet until she was in plenty of hot water.)
It’s fairly clear that Evans is not, in the final analysis, quite as bad as the movie makes him out to be. A lot of his purported wrongdoings are either harmless or actually quite reasonable: taking over breakfast because he claims eggs taste better when they’re whisked vigorously; obtaining a power of attorney so he can act on Holmes’s behalf while she’s in jail; interfering in Fielder’s attempt to record Holmes on a prison phone. He cuts a lot of conversations short, which makes him appear to be a very controlling person with something to hide - but obviously he could be the victim of selective editing. That’s not to say that he’s a good guy: he’s clearly got a weird paranoid streak; he’s a Charlie Kirk fan; he’s a rude, aggressive person and he posts to Holmes’s Twitter account under that character, for reasons passing understanding.
Evans’s foil, another person who acts as Holmes’s mouthpiece, is the actress Amanda Seyfried. Seyfried portrayed Holmes in the 2022 film The Dropout. In perfectly self-referential fashion, Fielder brings her into the project two years after filming Holmes and Evans, but before the film has been released. At first she is something of a neutral observer, reviewing the film to date and reacting to events as they transpire. She is meant to be something like the Greek chorus of old, guiding the audience in its reaction to the post-imprisonment developments in the saga. In this job she acquits herself quite admirably. Indeed, she seems to be the most trustworthy person in the entire project, despite the fact that she is an actress: a certain amount of artifice is her job!
As the movie winds up, however, Fielder recruits Seyfried to re-enact certain key moments in the story of the film itself. There’s a strange scene which depicts the negotiation of the rights to the film, and an utterly jaw-dropping scene in which Fielder visits Holmes in prison. Seyfried, acting the part of Holmes, literally says the following: “I’m tired of having other people speak for me.” This moment is Peak Fielder: self-referential art that comments, in not-so-subtle ways, on the nature of self-referentialism. Diderot would have been proud.
This movie needs to be seen in a theater, and I’m really glad I got the chance. The audience’s reaction is such a central part of the experience. I’ve read articles that describe audible gasps, but in my theater it was mostly laughs - I think partially uncomfortable ones. The above moment, with the prison visit, was the only one I can remember that really floored me. Though I certainly appreciated Seyfried watching a previously-recorded scene of Holmes watching a movie in which Seyfried herself is depicting Holmes. I am fairly certain that Fielder intended the experience to extend beyond the theater itself, and all of the post-release interviews making their way into the press are meant to be part of the ongoing saga.
This format and this storyteller are uniquely appropriate for this subject matter. Fielder himself makes a passing aside to his earliest series, 2013’s Nathan for You, which is a whimsical look at business schemes. Theranos was several orders of magnitude more deceptive than the kind of gimmicks Fielder was peddling in 2013, and the comparison between that show and Theranos is superficial in any case. On the other hand, 2022’s The Rehearsal was almost a pitch-perfect foreshadow of this movie. In this movie, Fielder brings that same self-referential, reality-imitates-art logic to bear on a woman who founded a company that was all about artifice, which became famous for a fake-it-till-you-make-it mentality. It’s almost as though The Rehearsal was really just an excuse for Fielder to exercise those techniques on a smaller and more targeted subject matter.
I don’t know if Fielder is interested in mathematics, but his movie is unwittingly a fascinating adaptation of some incredible mathematical insights into the world of filmmaking. Let’s accept, for the sake of argument, that Fielder is to documentary film what Gödel was to mathematics. Gödel’s theorem on incompleteness, quite famously, inspired Alan Turing’s work on the Entscheidungsproblem, and the attendant invention of the theoretical Turing machine. What was Theranos, but an attempt to invent a Turing machine for diagnostic medicine - a general purpose diagnostic device which could be adapted to any chemistry the lab tech desires? It’s oddly fitting that Holmes’s universal machine should be probed by Fielder’s work on incompleteness. Just as Gödel showed that no consistent mathematical system could be complete, so Fielder shows that no documentary can accurately capture the whole truth about its subject matter.
Now, what have we learned about Elizabeth Holmes, Theranos, and the larger questions involved in this case? Not a whole lot, certainly nothing much new. My best guess is that Holmes, who acts the guileless ingenue, is in fact quite smart and cunning, and knows more than a few things about plausible deniability and limited liability. That probably explains her persona in this film, the separation of responsibilities between her and Evans, and so forth. At one point in the film her father points out that she is a survivor of sexual assault - I did not know that, and it’s terrible. One has to wonder if that experience played a role in her strange relationship to the truth. Heartbreaking if so. I do not know a great deal about the crimes she was accused of, though it’s noteworthy to me that she was acquitted of clinical crimes and convicted of financial crimes - it’s not the first time our legal system has shown favor to the wealthy. From what I gather she projected a flashy image of her company, probably over-promised on an ambitious idea that just didn’t work out, and maybe used some creative storytelling to smooth out some rough edges in the technology - not all that different from lots and lots of other Silicon Valley entrepreneurs. Though she undoubtedly did a lot of harm, I also suspect she’s the victim of Martha Stewart syndrome: partially guilty of actual wrongdoing and partially guilty of being a strong woman.
The incredible thing I realized, as I made my way out of the theater, is that the story is not over. Holmes’s release date is 2030, at which point she’ll be in her mid-forties, with still another 20 or so years to her career. Perhaps she will yet prove us all wrong, and go on to make Theranos 2.0 a tremendous success, and reinvent health care as we know it! Maybe, in fact, you can see everything from the past - the future is certainly another question.